Godzilla Minus Zero Review: I wish I could give it that type of rating…
★★☆☆☆ (2 stars)
Okay, before anyone gets angry or bitter, I think that you should know that I was a huge fan of Godzilla Minus One – I still am. I didn’t see it in theatres, but word of mouth made me give it a look, on Netflix (I watched the colour version first before then switching to the black and white version), and I was in total awe. Not only of the technical aspects of it (CGI, production design, VFX) but most of all how it told an incredibly emotionally resonate story that felt bigger than any world-ending monster like Godzilla.
Who would have thought that in a Godzilla movie, the characters were the best part – yes, it was a spectacle to behold, but it was also a great drama, one that dealt with loss and trauma and a family coming together. I think I gave it a 4.5/5, so it’s safe to say I loved the film.
The same cannot be said about its sequel.
It has the spectacle; the VFX and CGI of the monsters are just as amazing (especially when you take into consideration the $18 million budget), but none of the tension. What exactly are the stakes? Yes, like the first there’s the fact that these giants could kill everyone and everything, but with the characters feeling incredibly one-dimensional and utterly stupid, I just couldn’t care any less what happened to them. The stakes that were in the first, the emotional ones, just were not present here.
There are a couple of good twists here and there, but the impact of the twist relies entirely on your attachment and care for the characters; of which I had none, so what could have been an emotional gut-punch ends up being very trivial. And that’s also much like most of this film.
They repeat beats from the first film of PTSD through another character, which to their credit is done differently to the first, but the over-acting from him and the majority of the cast is laughable at times. There’s a lot of screaming, shouting, and crying – but no nuance to their actions or reactions – it’s all incredibly one-note and in your face.
And then there are simply moments of immense stupidity from the filmmakers. Everything with the weather girl is so so so so so so bad, it feels like a parody of a terrible movie (that terrible movie being itself), the attempt at a moral dilemma is not only stupid and plain wrong, but also underdeveloped (so either way it doesn’t work), and the whole emotional dilemma at the end makes no sense when you take into consideration things that the characters did about an hour earlier into the film.
If I could summarise what this film is, I would say that it’s a director that feels like he has to do character work; it’s a chore for him, and he’s cutting it down as much as he can so he can get to the bit’s he likes – the action. You shouldn’t feel like you have to write and spend time with the characters, you should want to.
And I think the peak of my disappointment with this film was actually with myself. I felt like walking out of the theatre, it was that bad. You hear these stories of critics walking out of screenings, and I always looked down on those types of people – I could never understand why they would do something like that, so disrespectful, so wasteful. But now I get it, and the only reason why I stayed is because it was coming to an end (and I was with someone watching this).
So don’t go see this, it’s no better than any of the stuff Hollywood has put out in concern to Godzilla films, see the first if you haven’t (Minus One), because it’s great; and stands alone, this does not.
